2026 Easter Gift Guide

Mar 24, 2026

Easter has a way of inviting us to slow down, gather close, and celebrate the simple joys - good food, meaningful traditions, and the people we love most.

Whether you’re hosting brunch, bringing something special to the table, or sending a sweet surprise from afar, this year’s Easter gifting is all about comfort, connection, and a touch of indulgence. And what better way to celebrate than with something freshly baked and made with care?

Here’s your 2026 Easter Gift Guide - filled with heartfelt favorites and crowd-pleasing classics.

 

EASTER ESSENTIALS         UNDER $25         UNDER $40         

 


Easter Essentials:

Make your Easter gathering unforgettable with our curated selection of gifts and delicious essentials. Our Easter Feast Essentials, including the Easter Brunch Box and a delectable savory Chicken Pot Pie for Dinner, take the stress out of hosting, allowing you to enjoy the festivities with ease.

Easter Breakfast Box

Everything you need for an easy, beautiful Easter morning.
Our Easter Breakfast Box brings together a made-from-scratch quiche of your choice, your favorite signature sweet pie, and a warm, bakery-fresh finish with your choice of cinnamon rolls or NEW Sticky Buns.


It’s the kind of spread that feels thoughtful, generous, and completely effortless, so you can spend less time in the kitchen and more time around the table.  


Schedule a Shipment

Schedule for Pick-Up

 Easter Brunch Box

Deluxe Easter Breakfast Box

Easter morning, made even more generous.

Our Deluxe Easter Breakfast Box includes everything you need for a beautiful, effortless spread, now with two made-from-scratch quiches, so there is plenty to go around. Paired with your choice of signature sweet pie and either cinnamon rolls or our NEW sticky buns, it is a full table without the work.

Perfect for hosting, sharing, and making Easter morning feel as special as it should.

Schedule a Shipment

Schedule for Pick-Up


Key Lime Pie

Celebrate Easter with a tangy twist by indulging in our March Pie of the Month, Key Lime Pie. Bursting with zesty flavor and a creamy texture, this refreshing dessert is the perfect way to add a touch of brightness to your Easter table. Made with the finest ingredients and baked to perfection, our Key Lime Pie is sure to delight your taste buds and leave you craving more.  

Schedule a Shipment

Schedule for Pick-Up

 Key Lime Pie - Southern Baked Pie Company

Easter Stencil Pies

In-Store Exclusive - Available for pickup 3/30-4/4

Visit our store or order ahead, and choose your favorite signature pie flavor from options like Chocolate Chess, Buttermilk, and French Coconut. Then, select your stencil design, available in either an Easter Bunny or a Cross, made out of delicate powdered sugar. These beautifully crafted pies are not only a treat for your taste buds but also a feast for your eyes.

Schedule for Pick-Up

Easter Bunny Stencil Pie

Easter Topped Decorated Pies

In-Store Exclusive - Available for pickup 3/30-4/4

Whether you visit our store or preorder online, you can choose from our signature pie flavors such as Chocolate Chess, Buttermilk, and French Coconut. Each pie is then topped with Cadbury eggs, adding a delightful Easter-themed touch. Indulge in these beautifully decorated pies for a taste of Easter joy that is both delicious and charming.

Schedule for Pick-Up

Easter Egg-Topped Decorated Pie

Easter Tassies

In-Store Exclusive - Available for pickup 3/30-4/4

A dozen of the cutest bite-sized pies, festively decorated for Easter, and in a variety of flavors. Choose from Chocolate Chess, French Coconut & Lemon Chess flavors. Available by the dozen as a variety pack, or call the store to customize your order. 

Schedule for Pick-Up

Call to Order

Easter Tassies at the Pie Shops

Back to Top

 

Gifts Under $25:

Looking for thoughtful gifts that won't break the bank? Explore our variety featuring items like the Celebrate Life with Pie Cookbook and the SBP X Heirloomed Co Candle. These gifts are perfect for adding a touch of charm to any Easter basket or as a hosting gift.

Southern Baked: Celebrating Life With Pie Cookbook

Celebrating Life With Pie is filled with 72 delicious family recipes. Of the recipes, 32 are pie related; and the remaining consists of easy entrees, desserts, and appetizers to enjoy all year-round. Enjoy baking the dishes of the south that Amanda knows and loves oh so well! 

Schedule a Shipment

Schedule for Pick-Up

 
Celebrating Life With Pie Cookbook - 2023 Holiday Gift Guide

Gourmet Pecans

Mammoth Pecans, locally grown in Georgia, two decadent ways - Chocolate Amaretto and Salted & Roasted. Perfect to set out for holiday guests, or keep in their bag for an on-the-go snack. 

Schedule a Shipment

Schedule for Pick-Up

Gourmet Pecans - Chocolate Amaretto Pecans & Salted & Roasted Pecans

Gourmet Popcorn

Our gourmet popcorn flavors are sure to please! Order as a gift or treat yourself to the decadent flavors of Birthday Cake or Caramel Sea Salt! Each bag contains 1/2lb of gourmet popcorn in a resealable package. The perfect gift and perfect on-the-go snack!  

Schedule a Shipment

Schedule for Pick-Up

Gourmet Popcorn - Birthday Cake Popcorn & Caramel Sea Salt Popcorn

Southern Baked Pie Gift Card

Send it electronically via an email for any increment, or pick one up from your local pie shop. 

Send an E-Gift Card

Pick-Up In Store

Southern Baked Pie Gift Card - 2023 Holiday Gift Guide

Apple & Cherry Handpies

In-Store Exclusive

The Perfect Portable Pie - no sharing required.

Schedule a Pick-Up

Apple & Cherry Handpies

Back to Top

 

Gifts Under $40:

Explore our Gifts Under $40, where you'll find a range of delightful options to enhance your Easter celebration. From charming accessories to sweet indulgences, these gifts offer something special for everyone. Treat yourself or someone you love to a touch of Easter joy without breaking the bank. Discover the perfect gift to make this Easter season truly memorable!

A Signature Southern Baked Pie

One of our 4 Signature-Pie flavors are great for introducing to a new Southern Baked Pie fan!

Grab a classic Buttermilk Pie, the first pie that Amanda started Southern Baked with! The Caramel Pecan Pie - winner of the 2016 Taste of Georgia Contest, and featured in Garden & Gun Magazine. A decadent French Coconut Custard - highlighted on the Today Show with Hoda & Jenna. Or Amanda's personal favorite, Chocolate Chess Pie. With any of these flavors - you can't go wrong. 

Schedule a Shipment

Schedule for Pick-Up

 
Buttermilk, Caramel Pecan, Chocolate Chess, and French Coconut Pie - 2023 Holiday Gift Guide

The Pie Purse

Needing a gift for the one who's always running around, traveling, or always brings snacks to the game? This stylish, easy to clean, and TSA-Friendly bag makes the perfect hostess gift to stuff with their favorite goodies and pie!

P.S. It can hold up to 4 bottles of wine too.

Schedule a Shipment

Schedule for Pick-Up


Southern Baked Pie X Heirloomed Candle

Have their home smell like our Pie Shops with the Southern Baked Pie scented candle. Embrace the inviting aroma of freshly-baked pies & hints of vanilla. 

Schedule a Shipment

Schedule for Pick-Up

Southern Baked Pie Gift Card

Send it electronically via an email for any increment, or pick one up from your local pie shop. 

Send an E-Gift Card

Pick-Up In Store

Southern Baked Pie Company Gift Card - 2023 Holiday Gift Guide

4-Pack Petite Pie Box

Featured in O Magazine for Oprah's Favorite things: a variety pack of 5" individual pies in either sweet or savory flavors. Gift them convenience and minis to share...or not.

Schedule a Shipment

Schedule for Pick-Up

4-Pack Petite Pie Box - 2023 Holiday Gift Guide

Back to Top

As Easter approaches, let our gift guide inspire you to celebrate this special occasion with joy and thoughtfulness. Make this Easter a memorable one with our curated selection of gifts that are sure to delight your loved ones. From all of us at Southern Baked Pie Company, we wish you a blessed Easter filled with love, joy, and delicious moments shared with family and friends. 

 

Looking for a fun Easter-themed activity for the kids? 

Easter Pie Cookies & Icing

Check out this recipe for Homemade Easter Pie Crust Cookies.

Click Here to view the recipe.